If you live anywhere within the continental United States, chances are very good that you have house sparrows. These non-descript brown birds make their homes just about everywhere that we choose to make our homes, from city condos to country escapes, and all the suburbs and small towns in between. They are among the three most common birds in the country.
Despite their abundance, house sparrows are not native to the United States. The birds were deliberately introduced to North America several times in the mid-1800s, and haven’t looked back since.
I wish they would.
The trouble with house sparrows isn’t really their abundance. Nor is it their non-native status. No. The trouble with house sparrows is more basic — these birds are bullies.
House sparrows will readily chase native bluebirds and other cavity nesters from their homes. They will destroy the eggs of other birds, murder their chicks, and even attack, injure, and sometimes kill adult birds they find and trap in their nests.
As I said: bullies.
Now, some people may not mind. For someone who has never watched the cycle of courting, nest-building, and fledging, a nesting pair of house sparrows may even seem a welcome sight. If you are one of those people, I hope you’ll consider taking a different stance this coming spring. By discouraging house sparrows, you give native bluebirds, chickadees, titmice, and more a fighting chance.
Easy house sparrow deterrent
There are many ways to discourage house sparrows. Some people trap the birds. Others destroy their nests. I prefer to prevent their nesting in the first place. This requires a bit of time and awareness, but I feel that’s time well spent. Last year, for example, the nest boxes in and around the Outlaw Garden fledged two families of bluebirds, one family of chickadees, and one family of titmice. That’s some pretty great motivation!
My favorite way of discouraging house sparrows requires little more than a few thumb tacks or nails, scissors, a hammer, and some fishing line. Once you have your supplies gathered, it takes no more than a minute or two to protect each nest box.
What you’ll need
- thumbtacks with raised stem, or small nails / brads (about 8 per birdhouse)
- scissors
- hammer
- fishing line
What to do
Grab your supplies and head outside to your birdhouse(s). Using your hammer, gently pound four tacks or nails into the four corners of the roof. Attach two tacks or nails to the front of the roof, more-or-less directly above the bottom of the box. Finally, attach two tacks or nails to the bottom front corners of the box.
(Alternatively, use just two nails/tacks at the top front of the box. In the photos below, you’ll see this is what I’ve done.)
To begin, tie your fishing line to one of the tacks or nails on the roof. Pull it taut, and wrap it around the other nails/tacks both side-to-side, top-to-bottom and diagonally. You want the line to be approximately one-inch about the surface of the box. Once done, you should have created a square and an X out of the fishing line. Tie it off and cut off the excess.
Next, tie your fishing line to one of the four nails/tacks on the front of the box. Pull the line taut, and wrap it around every other nail/tack on the front until you have created a square of fishing line around the front of the entire box. Do not run diagonal lines. Tie off the line and cut off the excess.
Test the line with your fingers. It should be fairly taut.
That’s it. Done.
Why it works
No one really knows, but this little trick works very well (not 100% of the time, but close to it). House sparrows are spooked by the line, but it doesn’t seem to bother our native nesters, such as bluebirds, chickadees, or titmice. Perhaps house sparrows have worse eyesight, since they mostly eat seed. Maybe they think the fishing line is a spider web. Whatever the reason, it works.
The fishing line on the front of the box prevents house sparrows from landing and entering the box (most of the time). And, the fishing line on the top of the box spooks the males, who usually perch on top of boxes they’ve claimed.
Variations and considerations
Some recommend hanging loose line from the eaves of the box, and weighing them down with fishing weights. I do not do this because I worry about the risk of an adult bird becoming entangled in the line and/or pulling the line into the box with them. I just feel safer using line that is tied down and taut.
This deterrent works most of the time, but you may still experience trouble with some boxes. If house sparrows persist, consider adding more line, perhaps on longer nails so that the line is elevated higher above the box’s surface. Or, perhaps simply relocate the box.
Fishing line will degrade over time in the sunlight, and may eventually break or loosen from the tacks or nails. I recommend checking the condition of the line at least once a month, and replacing any line or tacks that look compromised. I generally remove the line entirely for the winter months, and replace it with fresh line in February or March, when birds start exploring potential nest sites.
Fishing line can entangle birds and other wildlife. When using this, please ensure that you remove all loose line from your yard or garden.
And that’s it!
If you have any additional suggestions for protecting bird houses from house sparrows, please share your tips in the comments section below.
Hello, and welcome to the Outlaw Garden! My name is Cristina Santiestevan, and I’m the outlaw gardener. I break the rules by growing vegetables in my suburban front yard, even though my HOA (homeowners association) says “no.” You can do the same — explore the site to learn how!
Great article. I haven’t put up bird houses, but someone gave me a couple as a gift. Thanks for the great advice 🙂
This is the perfect time to be setting out those birdhouses — lots of birds house-hunting right about now. Good luck!
An inspiring article for a true nature lover. I had a different perspective of sparrows which got change reading your article above. Only wonder whether while blocking sparrows, we can encourage the other winged birds like bluebirds etc to visit us more often… 🙂
Do keep up the good work. Wish you well!
Thanks, Mahesh! Best thing you can do to attract the good guys (bluebirds, chikadees, etc) is to provide some well-sized housing in your yard. Chickadees and titmice seem to prefer birdhouses set closer to trees, while bluebirds like to have a bit of open space around their boxes — a fence post works well for setting up bluebird boxes. Here’s an easy DIY plan for building your own birdhouse –> http://www.outlawgarden.com/2014/03/03/diy-simple-bird-house/
This is a great idea, I’ve never heard it before but have heard about their bullying habits. Thanks for sharing it with us!
This has worked so well in my garden. I’m in a suburban neighborhood, and there are LOTS of house sparrows here. A bit of fishing line seems to stop them every time, and the bluebirds, chickadees and titmice don’t seem to mind it at all. I hope it works for you, too!
Thanks so much for your article! I’ve been horrified by the brutal sparrows trying to take over my nest box with chickadees. As a new bird watcher/provider, I’ve been frustrated trying to get them to stop. I made a foil strip spooker, but can’t wait to do what you do to prevent this.
I have a log cabin with several nooks and crannies that they love to nest in. I’ve had SOME success with covering the areas with bird netting. I’ve also filled some of the holes with expanding foam — but the sparrows peck at the foam and eventually get in. Any other suggestions to deter? Thanks!
I’ve never tried deterring house sparrows from anything but birdhouses, so I’m just guessing here… You might try using fishing line to hang some old and wanted CDs or other bright and flashy object. Or, have you tried mounting a decoy owl or hawk near where they nest? If the holes aren’t too large, you might also be able to fill them with wood putty. It’d probably be more expensive than the spray foam, but the sparrows shouldn’t be able to damage the putty once dried. Good luck!
Thanks!
I just assembled the fishing line/tack to the house. I have a nesting pair of bluebirds who have lost two eggs this season to the house sparrows pecking and destroying them. The sweet bluebird couple have tried, again and there is a pretty blue egg in the box. The female bluebird has already been in her house. My concern with this deterrent is that I am unable to look inside the house due to the fishing wire obstructing opeing the roof door. Any suggestions?
You may want to attach the line to the roof and the house separately. So, one line on the roof, that moves when you open the roof. And, then one line on the front of the house near the entrance. It’s not a 100% deterrent, but it does help a lot. Good luck to you and those bluebirds!
Awesome idea – looks easier than the do it yourself magic halo – I did do a couple halos and they are not easy to do. How would you deter them from using the bird feeders – I have a magic halo with fishing lines on the feeder but they try to get under the fishing lines – it has been frustrating try to deter them but I wont give up – thanks for sharing
Magic halos are new to me. Neat idea! I’ve never used them before, but imagine the success would be about the same. As for bird feeders, I just don’t have any (so no advice to offer there). I focus on planting a lot of bird-friendly shrubs and flowers instead.
I had a chickadee nest in my bluebird house. Bluebirds not yet here (in Chicago suburbs). Chickadee was killed in a new bird house I put up. Very upsetting!
I will put these up ASAP. Now, I have to figure out something for my Kingman (concrete) bluebird house!
DO NOT put your bluebird or swallow houses out until after you have seen them in the area and then wait two weeks. Often these birds will have scouts that will examine the area to nest before the larger flocks of birds arrive. If you put your boxes out too early, the overwintering birds such as the House Sparrow will have first dibs to your nestbox. WAIT two weeks for larger numbers of desirable birds arrive to give them a chance to compete for the box. I have made this mistake before….
I tend to leave my boxes up all year (birds will use them for winter shelter too), but am also very watchful come springtime. Because, you’re right, house sparrows will definitely claim a birdhouse if given the chance.
I fought the sparrows last year. Tried to put in fake eggs, and tried to shake them so they wouldn’t hatch. (I have a bird=cam, so was able to watch them from my TV.) Still had to watch as they hatched and fledged before bluebirds nested in that box. This year, I will leave the side open and not close it until after I see bluebirds for a couple of weeks.
Thanks for the advice! Very helpful!
How do you put the line up on a Gilbertson house. Having a problem with sparrows getting into the nest of a regular box, now building in the Gilbertson house. Trying to prevent it from happening again. (even had a sparrow spooker up on that house too!) Need to know how to protect them in the Gilbertson house.
The Gilbertson style house… Is that the kind that’s often made out of a big PVC tube? I’m not sure. Maybe screw some small eye hooks into the house at a few strategic points, and then run the line through the eye hooks? Good luck!
doing this today! fingers crossed that it works!!!
did not work for us ?
Bummer. I’ve had a few extra stubborn sparrows as well. The deterrent seems to work best if it’s installed before the sparrows discover the box. But, even then, it’s no guarantee.
Do you have any recommendations for discouraging them at a feeder? I live in Oklahoma City, a decent size city so I don’t think trapping would even be effective. More would just take their place. The last 2 years I’ve had brown thrashers, cardinals, and Robins nest in my yard. While I know their nesting habits are different, I’m afraid the presence of so many sparrows may discourage them to nest here again, since they population has boomed. I’ve changed feeder styles, tried thistle, black oil, safflower…they eat whatever is out there. I could really use help if you have any suggestions. Even if the suggestion is don’t put a feeder out anymore…
No suggestions for the feeder except the one you’ve already thought of: just eliminate the feeder. I will say that I haven’t noticed any sort of negative impacts caused by the house sparrows on birds that don’t nest in cavities. Hopefully that means your thrashers and cardinals and robins may be just fine.
After hours of researching how to keep sparrows away from our feeders, we finally found a resolution! The idea came from a university who came up with the idea. We then found the website below and a place selling it for approximately $40.
Prior to investing in the Halo, I tried this:
Split 2 wooden paint stir sticks lengthwise with utility knife
Duct taped them in an X shape under the canopy of the birdfeeder
Tied 5’ of fishing wire on all 4 ends
Cost? Zero $
After we installed we watched sparrows for 4 days trying to come in for the landing but they’d do a fast 180. No more sparrows, or doves, or flickers!
The look isn’t great but now that we know it works we’ll either be gluing the sticks in place under the canopy; or a small single tomato tower ring or something like an embroidery hoop and place it above the canopy for less of a homemade look.
http://www.sialis.org/halo.htm#:~:text=Quick%20tip%3A%20To%20deter%20House,with%20millet%20and%20cracked%20corn.
I am wondering if the fishing line technique will deter my tree swallows.
Also the shiny tape. Will it deter my swallows too?
We were wondering the same thing. We had a House Sparrow take over a Tree Swallow birdhouse this weekend, and it destroyed the Swallow eggs. Will the Swallows be okay with this?
I have sparrows preventing a welcome robin from building a nest for the second time this year. they tore apart the nest earlier this year, and we noticed them doing the same thing this morning. We would like to welcome all birds to our yard, but do not wish to put up with these bullies. I have found your advice hopeful for the near future to be able to welcome the smaller birds. (the sparrows have babies in a birdhouse now, and we try to let all creatures live.) Do you have any advice to deter the sparrows, but still encourage the robins, cardinals, blue jays, etc…?
This works great! I had several sparrows going after a bird house I have with baby Chickadees in it. I put the thumbtacks and line up. now the sparrows are afraid to go to the bird house but the Chickadee parents are back, going in and out. Thank you for this article!